Personal Rating: 3.5 Stars Goodreads Rating at time of review: 3.62 Stars Content Rating: Light PG-13 Trigger Warnings: Fantasy substance abuse, anxiety, depression, absent parent, some body horror (people growing flowers out of skin, chest, lungs, etc.) Clara’s magic has always been wild. But it’s never been dangerous. Then a simple touch causes poisonous flowers to bloom in her father’s chest. The only way to heal him is to cast an extremely difficult spell that requires perfect control. And the only person willing to help is her former best friend, Xavier, who’s grown from a sweet, shy child into a mysterious and distant young man. Xavier names a terrible price in return, knowing Clara will give anything to save her father. As she struggles to reconcile the new Xavier with the boy she once loved, she discovers their bargain is only one of the heavy secrets he’s hiding. And as she hunts for the truth, she instead finds the root of a terrible darkness that’s taken hold in the queendom—a darkness only Clara’s magic is powerful enough to stop. (goodreads.com) The copy of this book that I own is the Fae Crate exclusive edition, so if you’d like to see what that cover looks like, scroll on down to the bottom of this review! Both are magnificent covers, so please take a moment to appreciate the beauty! Alright, obligatory pretty cover comment out of the way, let’s get into the actual review. I was so, so, so excited for this book! A cottagecore fantasy with flower magic and a bit of romance? Sounds lovely, sign me up! And it was lovely, it was also just a twinge disappointing. I think part of that was because I set my hopes unattainably high and did not prepare for anything less than exactly what I wanted. It was still a fun book, it just wasn't the warm cottagecore hug I was hoping for. My first disappointment with it was the world building. Well, the lack of world building. And I know world building in a cozy fantasy is not always a top priority, and generally not all important to the plot, but I still would have liked a bit more. The reader is dropped into a world and told there are magic users, that those magic users have a council of some sort, and that young magicians are apprenticed to older magicians. All of which is relevant to the plot and great. However, there isn’t really much expansion on that information. We get small details about what the magician’s code of ethics is like and how they use their magic, but not much else. And the rest of the world is never explored. We know it’s a queendom, which sounds really cool and interesting, but I don’t recall them mentioning any information about the queen or what the queendom looks like outside of Clara’s small town and Xavier’s family home. My default guess for books like this that feature cottages and manors, is that the world is inspired by the English countryside, but there aren’t many clues confirming that, so that imagined world only fits because of my own background in reading fantasy. There also isn’t really a “set time period”. Obviously, this is not set in our world so no time period would line up with it exactly, but most fantasy worlds are inspired, at least with fashion and technology, by a point in our world’s history. Lord of the Rings, for example, has some decidedly medieval aesthetics going on. Based on the dress Clara wears on the cover, I’d guess Flowerheart is supposed to be late Victorian or early Edwardian, but hardly anything in the actual book points to that. The Victorian/Edwardian eras have some great technology that would have been a fun way to set the mood, like a gramophone or mention of trains or maybe even something with an Industrial Revolution nod. Again, it’s not vital to the plot that we have an exact picture of the world the story takes place in, but it would have been nice to be able to visualize it a little better. Apart from that, it really would have been cool to know more about how magic works in their world. Are the magicians the only difference from their world and ours or are there other things? Magical creatures? Odd geography? Legends of magic? Deities? I’m not saying not knowing these things makes it a bad story, but I, personally, would have enjoyed it more with more context. What little the reader does get to know about the fantasy world this is set in reminds me a little of Ingary, the place where Howl's Moving Castle by Diana Wynne Jones is set. Which was fun, but again, I'm drawing from my own reading experiences and not being given anything new from this book. I did like the plot. I mostly liked the writing style (I’m a bit exhausted of first person perspective, but that’s a me problem). The flower descriptions were so fun and I loved that we got to see some “language of the flowers” action. I would adore it if more books used the language of the flowers, ever since I read the Enola Holmes books by Nancy Springer I’ve been interested and Flowerheart has rekindled the obsession. I thought the characters were lovely. Albert Lucas, Clara’s father, was adorably sweet. The various magicians Clara met with were interesting and I would have loved to hear more about them. And I liked that Xavier felt realistic for a teenager burdened with large responsibilities. He acted mature and formal much of the time, but there were little instances of bashfulness and awkwardness that made him seem genuine. The book was easy to get into and be drawn into, but there were points that lagged for me. The pacing was not quite right. There were moments when it seemed like it was trying really hard to be a slow, cozy read, but then other moments when everything was happening at the speed of light and all of a sudden there are new problems, or old problems are solved in the blink of an eye. And the slow, cozy moments were not always well connected to the rest of the story, which is why I had to set it down several times. I kept thinking “why are we focused on this right now? Clara’s dad is dying!”, or “okay, things are calm, now would be a good time for some cute warm scenes--oh, nevermind people have dandelions growing out of their faces”. However, as a whole, I did like this book, I just didn’t love it. Not as much as I was hoping to anyway. Still, I could see myself picking up a sequel if there is one (most of the dilemmas were tied up, but there were enough openings that a sequel is possible) for a quick fantasy read. If you like diverse, mid-stakes (I don’t want to say “low-stakes” because her father was dying, but it doesn’t feel like incredibly “high-stakes” either because I was never too worried about the guy), cottagecore, teenage romances, you should check out Flowerheart. If you don’t… well, okay, I dunno, check out another one of my reviews and see if you can find something you like, I guess. Thank you for reading, I am off to check the magical cabinet that has delicious treats in it. Until next time! Image source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/61319750-flowerheart
0 Comments
|
Categories
All
Archives
April 2024
|